The Southern Corruption Of Short Stories English Literature Essay Free Essay
The short narratives, “ A Good adult male is Difficult to Find ” by Flannery O’Conner and “ A Rose for Emily ” by William Faulkner are instead dismaying ; one narrative is about a grandma and her household viciously murdered by a coldhearted slayer, and the other narrative is about a lady who murders her lover and so kip beside his decomposing organic structure. Not merely have O’Conner and Faulkner created similar secret plans in their several narratives, both writers criticize the Southern corruptness through the deformation of the characters ‘ universe position of world.
Both the grandma in O ‘ Conner ‘s narrative and Emily in Faulkner ‘s choose to recapture the yesteryear and are unable to accept the alterations in the present, reflecting a prevailing attitude and thought in the South. In “ A Good Man is Difficult to Find, ” the grandma is nostalgic of the “ better ” yesteryear, in which she grounds that a “ good adult male ” was easier to happen a long clip ago ; she believes that prosecuting goodness in the present is hard and even pointless. During the household ‘s trip to Florida, the grandma scolds her grandchildren to act courteously, as she explains, “ In my timeaˆ¦children were more respectable of their native provinces and their parents and everything else. Peoples did right so ” ( O ‘ Conner 546 ) . As shown in this scene, the grandma constantly refers back to the yesteryear in order to carry others to move in ways she desires. Similarly, the Southern deformation resulted from people idealising the yesteryear and utilizing that as a tool to pull strings people ‘s apprehension of the universe. By self-blinding herself from the universe unconsciously, the grandma is able to get away from the unpleasant world in both the yesteryear and nowadays. Therefore, she is merely familiar about the pleasant characteristics of the yesteryear, uncovering the common factor which led to the corruptness in the South. Likewise, in “ A Rose for Emily, ” Emily herself depicts the more traditional character who persistently stays the same over the old ages irrespective of many alterations in her society. At the funeral, the storyteller of the narrative describes that “ Miss Emily had been a responsibility, a tradition, and a attention ; a sort of familial duty upon the town ” ( Faulkner 1 ) . Emily is exemplified as a relic of the water under the bridge yearss, from the fact that her house is the last trace of the yesteryear in a one time elegant, upscale vicinity. Emily is unable to interrupt free from the yesteryear, which is besides seen when she refuses to pay the revenue enhancements because she still believes that Colonel Sartoris, the town city manager who suspended her revenue enhancements, is alive though he died 10 old ages ago. Harmonizing to the grandma and Emily, the present is full of ambiguity and sadness, and things were much better long ago. Therefore, when the supporters encounter characters who bring alterations and new thoughts, merely as the South encountered North ‘s advanced perceptual experience of sing the universe at a different angle, Emily and the grandma experience ruin. In “ A Rose for Emily, ” Homer Barron brings invention to Emily ‘s life as he starts a relationship with her.A Homer symbolizes modernness, a force of promotion that is turning over the traditional values and arousing apprehensiveness and resistance among diehards. However, Emily does non cognize how to respond to the new thoughts that Homer brings, so he ends up as a victim of her program to maintain him for good by her side. Through the puzzling character, Emily Grierson, Faulkner conveys the strive from seeking to continue tradition in the face of extremist, widespread alteration, similar to when the Southerners attempted to maintain their tradition when the Northerners forced them to alter their traditional life style. In “ A Good Man is Difficult to Find, ” the grandma faces alteration when she meets the Misfit and his pack after the auto accident.A She is up against the Misfit, a force that will alter things irrevocably, because all of her beliefs and biass do non count any longer to the barbarous felon. Since the grandma is unable to alter her rigorous position of the universe against the Misfit, she is killed, typifying the devastation of traditional values and the transmutation into the modern epoch. Despite the supporters ‘ attempts to remain true to the old imposts, their ruins demonstrate that their old Southern values are out of topographic point in a modernizing society.
We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!
The usage of sarcasm in the character ‘s societal positions and their suffering lives illustrate the writers ‘ unfavorable judgment of the Southern societal construction. The narratives include penetrations into the households of the old South, and the older category system of wealth and aristocracy. Both the grandma and the household that Emily comes from have really rigorous impressions about the upper category society, and the outlook is for nice behaviour. As a consequence, when the townsfolk notice the gross outing olfactory property from Emily ‘s house in “ A Rose for Emily, ” they begin to feel for the progressively recluse Emily, claiming, “ It was another nexus between the gross, pullulating universe and the high and mighty Griersons ” ( Faulkner 2 ) . Not merely that, as Homer becomes a popular person in town and is witnessed of taking Emily on roadster drives on Sunday afternoons, it shocks the town and augments the commiseration and contempt they have for Emily. They believe that she is burying the pride in her high-toned household and going involved with a adult male below her category. Even though Emily is from the high category household, it does non intend that she is populating up to the pleasant life style. As a affair of fact, she is really populating a glooming and bare life, which is basically the opposite life style expected for Emily ‘s rank in society by the townsfolk. Emily ‘s bequest has changed, doing her more an duty and responsibility than an idealised vitamin D leftover of a deceasing order, though Emily was one time a symbol of Southern tradition focus oning on the landed aristocracy with their huge belongings and significant resources. In “ A Good Man is Difficult to Find, ” despite the grandma ‘s evident belief in her moral supremacy-which she expresses through her self-proclaimed designation as a lady and spiritual teaching-the grandma is non a “ good ” adult female. As a life memorial of the yesteryear, she represents the high social rank that people desire to honour and esteem ; however, she is besides a load who is wholly cut off from the outside universe, holding eccentricities that others can non understand. Although the social places of the supporters suggest that their lives are distinguished and full of pleasance, in world, they end up populating a forlorn and disadvantaged life without being able to achieve felicity.
Racism, which was apparent in both narratives, depicts the influence of Southern civilization on the two supporters. They are both prejudiced as anyone else populating in this clip of epoch, though bondage was officially non allowed any longer. In “ A Rose for Emily, ” Emily herself has a black retainer, and is non surprised when “ [ the ] Negro bringing male child brought her the bundle ; the pharmacist did n’t come back ” ( Faulkner 4 ) . The drug shop seller makes the Negro to sell the deadly arsenous anhydride to Emily, so the seller himself will non acquire into problem. The arsenic she bought from the Negro is subsequently used in Emily ‘s offense, which shows that Emily was so accustomed to looking down upon other human existences that she did non waver to kill her lover. From the incident, Faulkner criticizes Emily for being influenced by the racialist position of Southern civilization, which led her to perpetrate slaying. Similarly, in “ A Good Man is Difficult to Find, ” the grandma behaves in a condescending mode toward the black kids as she claims, “ Small niggas in the state do n’t hold things like we do ” ( O ‘ Connor 546 ) . The grandma looks down on the inkinesss, which triggers her to be chesty and haughty of her white race. The racial bias in the South manipulates the grandma to keep disdainful attitudes toward others who she feels are inferior to her. Due to her egotistic attack she has when seeking to convert the Misfit to halt perpetrating offenses, the grandma ends up acquiring killed by the Misfit, who became abhorrent to her rebuke. Therefore, both Emily and the grandma are criticized by the writers for take parting in the act of racism, which was still apparent in that clip period in the South.
The grandma and Emily populate by their ain moral codifications that affect their determinations, actions, and perceptual experiences which exemplify the perversion of morality in the South. In “ A Good Man us Hard to Find, ” the grandma has created her ain onionskin and inconsistent moral codification on the features that she believes make people “ good. ” For case, the grandma thinks Red Sammy is “ good, ” because he is pensive of the past and trusts people blindly. Besides, she assumes that Misfit is “ good ” because she grounds that he will non kill a lady-a denial that would be in maintaining with her moral codification, as she claims to the Misfit, “ You ‘ve got good blood! I know you would n’t hit a lady! I know you come from nice people! Pray! Jesus, you ought non to hit a lady ” ( O’Connor 555 ) . However, her premise proves to be false, because the Misfit ends up killing her. This incident typifies that the grandma ‘s guess of world is non needfully valid, due to the Southern corruptness when people were unable to calculate out what is good or incorrect. Following, in “ A Rose for Emily, ‘ Emily implements her ain judgement for regulation and mode, such as when she asserts her ground for obtaining the toxicant or refuses to pay her revenue enhancements. Emily besides avoids the jurisprudence when she rebuffs to hold the Numberss assigned to her house when the federal mail service is introduced. Her dismissal of the jurisprudence finally takes on more baleful punishments, as she murders the adult male whom she refuses to let go forthing her. Due to the Southern perversion of ethical motives, the grandma and Emily were unable to acknowledge what is genuinely good or bad.
Around the 1930s was a clip of depression and corruptness of Southern civilization. Many Southerners ‘ visions of the universe were significantly altered and were maneuvered to move iniquitously. Consequently, both writers of the short narratives, “ A Good Man is Difficult to Find ” and “ A Rose for Emily ” knock the characters ‘ nostalgia of the yesteryear, sarcasm of societal places, manifestation of racism, and the perversion of morality as facets of Southern corruptness.